Behr vs Sherwin Williams Paint

When it comes to transforming your home with a fresh coat of paint, two brands often dominate the conversation: Behr and Sherwin Williams. Each has carved out a loyal following and continues to innovate in a competitive market. But how do you decide which paint brand is best for your project? From historical context and product offerings to environmental impact, cost analysis, durability, and expert opinions, this in-depth guide will give you the clarity you need to make an informed choice.

We’ll explore everything from the legacy of these two paint giants to practical application tips, emerging color trends, real-life case studies, and beyond. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly which brand aligns with your goals—whether you’re a DIYer on a budget or a seasoned contractor looking for the highest quality. Let’s dive in!

Tools and materials for painting, including paint cans, swatches, and a brush.

1. Historical Background

Understanding the origins and evolution of paint brands can reveal how they’ve shaped the industry and why they stand out. Let’s begin by delving into the rich histories of Sherwin Williams and Behr.

1.1 The Story of Sherwin Williams

Sherwin Williams has a legacy spanning over 150 years, making it one of the oldest paint companies in the United States. Established in 1866, Sherwin Williams was founded by Henry Sherwin and Edward Williams with a vision to produce consistently high-quality paints that cater to various needs—from household touch-ups to large-scale commercial projects. Early on, the company introduced groundbreaking innovations such as the first resealable paint can, which dramatically altered how professionals and homeowners stored and handled paint.

Over the decades, Sherwin Williams has maintained an unrelenting focus on research and development. Through constant innovation, they’ve created some of the most advanced paint formulations, earning them a reputation as a premium brand among contractors, homeowners, and even global industries like aerospace and automotive manufacturing. Notable achievements include:

  • Harmony Line: Zero-VOC paints that set an industry benchmark for eco-friendly coatings.
  • ColorSnap® System: A proprietary technology making it easier than ever to select and match colors, reducing guesswork.

Today, Sherwin Williams operates nearly 4,000 retail locations across the U.S., ensuring consistent quality control and personalized customer service. Professional painters, interior designers, and DIY enthusiasts all recognize the brand for its long-lasting durability, exceptional coverage, and robust color offerings.

1.2 The Rise of Behr

In contrast to Sherwin Williams’ mid-19th-century beginnings, Behr emerged in 1947 as a small, family-owned business focusing primarily on wood stains and varnishes. Founded by Otho Behr Jr., the company gradually built a reputation for responding swiftly to customer feedback and adopting industry trends. As the home improvement sector expanded in the post-war era, Behr seized the opportunity to broaden its product line to include interior and exterior paints.

A significant milestone for Behr was its strategic partnership with Home Depot in 1978. This alliance drastically increased brand visibility, making Behr paints readily accessible to millions of homeowners across the United States. Over time, Behr has honed a reputation for offering user-friendly, budget-conscious, and vibrantly hued paint solutions. Popular product lines such as Premium Plus Ultra and Marquee underscore Behr’s commitment to innovation and customer satisfaction.

1.3 Brand Philosophies and Business Culture

  • Sherwin Williams: Emphasizes professional-grade solutions, in-depth color consultations, and cutting-edge R&D. Their internal culture revolves around providing top-tier products suitable for a broad array of clients, from large-scale commercial painters to homeowners working on a weekend project.
  • Behr: Ingrained with a DIY-friendly ethos, Behr is known for simplicity, reliability, and easy-to-use products. The brand promotes accessibility by partnering with large retail chains, offering convenient one-stop shopping for both novices and experienced DIY enthusiasts.

These philosophical differences often guide product development, marketing strategies, and how each brand serves its target market. Understanding these dynamics equips you with insight into why each brand excels in different areas and appeals to different audiences.

2. Product Offerings: A Detailed Comparison

Paint cans and color palettes scattered across a surface.

Both Sherwin Williams and Behr house extensive product lines that cater to a wide range of needs—be it a child’s bedroom, a sprawling living room, or a commercial office space.

2.1 Color Selection

A well-chosen paint color can completely transform a space. Whether you’re looking to create a cozy retreat, a professional atmosphere, or a statement wall, the right hue plays a pivotal role.

  • Sherwin Williams: Boasts an impressive catalog of over 1,700 colors, plus the ability to craft custom shades through its proprietary ColorSnap® system. This system offers in-store and online tools to visualize how a color will look in real-world settings, a boon for both homeowners and professionals.
  • Behr: Provides a slightly smaller yet still vast palette of 1,400+ colors, supported by the Behr Paint Visualizer. This digital tool allows you to preview colors on virtual rooms, giving you confidence before committing to a specific paint.

Popular color choices from each brand often include:

  • Behr Breezeway: A soothing green-gray ideal for bathrooms or tranquil living spaces.
  • Sherwin Williams Sea Salt: A muted aqua for subtle sophistication in kitchens and bedrooms.
  • Behr MQ1-15: A bold accent hue that adds a vibrant splash to focal walls.
  • Sherwin Williams Tricorn Black: A modern black that delivers sleek elegance when used for trims or feature walls.

Sherwin Williams frequently updates its palette with timeless classics, while Behr leans into bold, modern trends. Meanwhile, the custom matching service at Sherwin Williams ensures no color is off-limits, giving decorators and homeowners unparalleled freedom.

2.2 Specialty Paints

Specialty paints often come into play when you have unique conditions—like high moisture, direct sunlight, or surfaces prone to constant wear. Both brands offer lines tailored to these specialized scenarios:

  • Sherwin Williams Duration Paint: Known for mildew resistance, exceptional durability, and ability to withstand high traffic. A go-to choice for kitchens, bathrooms, and busy hallways.
  • Behr Premium Plus Ultra: Marketed as a paint-and-primer-in-one, simplifying the painting process for busy homeowners. Its thick, rich consistency makes coverage more consistent, especially when painting over light surfaces.

Additionally:

When it comes to low-VOC or eco-friendly options, both brands meet modern environmental standards. Sherwin Williams Harmony has earned acclaim for its zero-VOC formula and odor-absorbing technology, while Behr Marquee Interior provides low-VOC coverage with an impressive color range.

2.3 Finishes and Sheens

Paint finishes have a major impact on the final look of a room and its practicality. Both Behr and Sherwin Williams offer:

  • Flat/Matte: Non-reflective, ideal for hiding imperfections on walls. Best for low-traffic areas like formal living rooms or bedrooms.
  • Eggshell: A subtle sheen that’s easier to clean than flat paint. Works well in moderately busy spaces like dining rooms.
  • Satin: Popular for its slightly higher sheen and durability, making it great for kitchens, bathrooms, and trim work.
  • Semi-Gloss: Reflects more light, suitable for trim, doors, and furniture. Its durability allows for easy cleaning.
  • High Gloss: Extremely reflective, excellent for highlighting architectural details or for a luxe finish on doors.

Choosing the right finish depends on both aesthetic preference and practical considerations (like how often you’ll need to wipe down the surface).

2.4 Color Matching Technology

In an era where personalization is king, color matching can make or break a project. Sherwin Williams’ ColorSnap® system is renowned for its precision, using advanced spectrophotometers to analyze color samples and produce an identical match. Behr’s in-store color matching service at Home Depot is also robust, but some users report that it might take a few tries to get an exact match—especially for more nuanced shades.

Both brands provide mobile apps and online resources to streamline color selection. Whether you’re snapping a photo of a throw pillow for inspiration or comparing a shade you spotted on Pinterest, you can quickly see how each brand’s colors stack up against your vision.

3. Durability and Longevity

A well-painted home entry corridor with stairs.

Few home improvement investments are as noticeable or frequently scrutinized as a paint job. The durability and longevity of your chosen paint can impact how often you’ll need to repaint, how your walls stand up to daily life, and how good they look over time.

3.1 High-Traffic Areas

Sherwin Williams Duration stands out for its resilience in high-traffic or high-moisture areas like kitchens and bathrooms. Its advanced formula resists scuffing, fading, and cracking, ensuring a finish that remains vibrant for years. Meanwhile, Behr Marquee is celebrated for offering one-coat coverage in many scenarios, saving time. However, some professional painters argue that Duration edges out Marquee in the long run because it can handle repeated cleaning without losing luster.

If you have children or pets, consider investing in Sherwin Williams Emerald Interior or Duration Home. These lines are formulated to endure rough treatment and frequent washing. While Behr also performs well under daily wear, professionals may lean toward Sherwin Williams for the most demanding environments.

3.2 Exterior Applications

Painting your home’s exterior poses unique challenges—prolonged sun exposure, temperature fluctuations, precipitation, and more. Sherwin Williams Emerald Exterior and SuperPaint excel in such environments. Many homeowners report that Sherwin Williams exterior paints maintain color richness for a decade or longer, particularly in extreme climates like coastal areas or deserts.

On the Behr side, Premium Plus Ultra Exterior and Marquee Exterior deliver sturdy performance at a more budget-friendly price. They incorporate UV-resistant technology to combat fading, though some users in harsh climates note they may need to repaint a bit sooner compared to Sherwin Williams. Ultimately, for moderate climates or smaller budgets, Behr remains a strong contender.

3.3 Long-Term Maintenance Considerations

Beyond initial application, you’ll want to think about:

  1. Cleaning: How often you need to wipe or wash your walls, especially in busy households.
  2. Touch-Ups: Both Sherwin Williams and Behr offer “sample sizes” of your paint, which can be indispensable for small nicks and scratches.
  3. Recoat Intervals: Industry norms suggest interior walls might need repainting every 5-7 years, whereas high-quality exterior paints can last 7-10 years or more, depending on climate and prep work.

Pro Tip: Whichever paint you choose, proper surface prep and correct application can significantly increase paint longevity. Even the most premium paints will underperform if the surface is dirty, greasy, or otherwise compromised before painting.

4. Environmental Impact

Eco-friendly paint cans labeled "Low VOC" surrounded by plants.

As homeowners grow increasingly eco-conscious, paint brands have adapted by offering low-VOC and no-VOC products, along with more sustainable manufacturing and packaging practices.

4.1 VOCs and Air Quality

Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) are chemicals emitted as paint dries, contributing to poor indoor air quality and potential health issues. Both Sherwin Williams and Behr have lines dedicated to reducing or eliminating VOCs:

  • Sherwin Williams Harmony: Zero VOCs, plus odor-eliminating technology. Highly recommended for nurseries, hospitals, or any interior space where air quality is paramount.
  • Behr Ultra and Marquee: While not zero-VOC, many formulations are low-VOC, especially once tinted. For the average homeowner, these levels often meet personal and regulatory standards.

4.2 Sustainability Initiatives

Beyond VOC reduction, both brands take strides in sustainability:

  • Sherwin Williams: Implements recyclable packaging and water-based formulations, reduces solvent usage during manufacturing, and invests in research to create more eco-friendly processes.
  • Behr: Focuses on efficient paint-and-primer combos that cut down on the number of coats required, which can reduce overall resource consumption.

Each brand publishes annual or periodic sustainability reports, detailing achievements and ongoing environmental goals. Checking these reports can provide deeper insights into how each company meets your personal or professional standards for eco-consciousness.

4.3 Certifications and Industry Standards

Major organizations grant certifications to paints that meet stringent environmental and performance criteria:

  • GreenGuard Gold: Indicates low chemical emissions, contributing to healthier indoor environments.
  • LEED Credits: Architects and contractors working on LEED-certified buildings often opt for paints that contribute points toward energy efficiency and sustainability.
  • MPI Green Performance Standard: Paints that pass these tests demonstrate a commitment to minimal environmental impact.

Sherwin Williams holds various certifications across multiple product lines, including GreenGuard for its Harmony paint. Behr is also ramping up certifications, especially for newer formulations, reflecting a growing commitment to meeting higher environmental standards.

5. Practical Application Tips

A painter using a roller to apply paint smoothly.

Regardless of the brand, proper preparation and technique can significantly affect your final result. Here’s how to get the most out of your paint, whether it’s Behr or Sherwin Williams.

5.1 Surface Preparation

  1. Clean the Surface: Use a mild detergent or TSP solution to remove dust, grease, or debris. This ensures the paint adheres properly.
  2. Repair and Fill: Patch holes and cracks with a suitable filler or spackle. Sand the area smooth once it’s dry.
  3. Primer: For darker surfaces or stains, using a dedicated primer can make a massive difference—even if you’re using a paint-and-primer-in-one product. Primer helps seal the surface and enhances color vibrancy.

Pro Tip: If you’re painting over glossy or semi-gloss finishes, lightly sand the surface to improve adhesion. This minimizes peeling or flaking later on.

5.2 Application Tools and Techniques

  • Behr Paints: Generally have a thicker consistency, which can require high-quality brushes or sprayers. Some DIYers appreciate this thickness for its forgiving coverage, but it can also mean that roller lines or brush strokes appear if you aren’t careful.
  • Sherwin Williams Paints: Tend to be slightly thinner, making them easier for pros to apply evenly with sprayers or rollers. A consistent motion and the right roller nap are crucial.

Rolling Technique: Use a “W” or “M” pattern on the wall and fill in the gaps for a smooth, uniform finish. Keep a wet edge and avoid going back over paint once it starts drying.

Brush Technique: Load your brush appropriately (about a third of the bristles) and gently tap off the excess. Long, smooth strokes minimize brush marks. When painting corners or small areas, consider angled brushes for greater control.

5.3 Common Painting Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

  • Skipping Primer: Even if your paint is marketed as paint-and-primer-in-one, it may not replace a dedicated primer in challenging scenarios (e.g., drastically changing colors or covering stains).
  • Over-Rolling: Rolling back over an area that’s partially dry can cause texturing or peeling.
  • Rushing the Dry Time: Follow the paint’s recommended recoat times. Humidity, temperature, and ventilation can extend dry times.
  • Using Cheap Tools: Low-quality brushes and rollers can lead to uneven application, lint stuck in the paint, or bristle shedding.

By investing in proper preparation and quality tools, you can significantly enhance the longevity and appearance of your paint job—no matter which brand you choose.

6. Cost and Accessibility

A woman in the Home Depot paint aisle browsing options.

When comparing Behr and Sherwin Williams, pricing and availability often dominate the conversation. Let’s break down the differences.

6.1 Pricing Structures

  • Sherwin Williams: Generally on the premium end, with prices ranging from $40 to $100 per gallon. Lines like Emerald and Duration command higher prices due to proprietary technology and exceptional durability.
  • Behr: Known for being budget-friendly, starting as low as $25 per gallon for base-tier products. Even top-tier lines like Marquee typically remain below the cost of comparable Sherwin Williams lines.

Though Sherwin Williams tends to be pricier, these costs often reflect longer-lasting formulations and a robust support network for both pros and homeowners.

6.2 Availability and Where to Buy

  • Sherwin Williams: Sold exclusively at Sherwin Williams retail stores or online via the company’s official website. This can be a drawback in terms of geographic convenience, but it also ensures a controlled supply chain and consistent product quality.
  • Behr: Sold primarily through Home Depot (both in-store and online), making it widely available in urban, suburban, and many rural areas. If there’s a Home Depot nearby, you can access Behr paints and consult their staff for recommendations.

In terms of online ordering, both brands provide tools to help you purchase paint without leaving your home. Sherwin Williams offers delivery or store pickup options, while Behr can be shipped directly from Home Depot’s extensive distribution network.

6.3 Professional Discounts and Loyalty Programs

For contractors and frequent DIYers, loyalty programs and professional discounts can be a game-changer:

  • Sherwin Williams PRO+: Offers tiered discounts, specialized credit options, and personal service from paint experts. Large-volume purchases often yield substantial price breaks, making Sherwin Williams more cost-effective for big projects.
  • Behr Pro Rewards: Targeted at professional painters who use Behr products regularly, offering discounts, bulk pricing, and priority customer service. While the discounts can be significant, some pros still lean toward Sherwin Williams for its comprehensive in-store support and color matching expertise.

7. Warranties, Return Policies, and Support

Both Sherwin Williams and Behr understand that paint issues can arise, and they offer warranties and customer support to address these concerns:

  • Sherwin Williams: Some high-end lines come with limited lifetime warranties. They also provide technical support through in-store consultations, ensuring you’re well-guided from color selection to application.
  • Behr: Notable for its lifetime limited warranty on select products like Premium Plus and Marquee. Since Behr is sold through Home Depot, you can often take advantage of Home Depot’s generous return policy, especially if you purchased unused paint.

What to Check: Warranty coverage usually requires following the brand’s recommended prep and application instructions. Keep your receipt and document any issues with photos. Proactive communication with the paint store or the brand’s customer service team can result in color corrections, product exchanges, or refunds if you’re unsatisfied.

8. Customer Reviews and Case Studies

A beautifully painted living room showcasing Behr and Sherwin Williams finishes.

Opinions from actual users—both professionals and DIYers—can offer valuable insights into the real-world performance of these paints.

8.1 Insights from Professionals

Professional painters often favor Sherwin Williams for commercial jobs or high-end residential projects due to the consistent quality control, color accuracy, and durability. It’s also easier to scale up with Sherwin Williams if you’re painting multiple rooms or even multiple houses, thanks to their bulk discounts and nationwide store network dedicated to professional accounts.

That said, many pros also use Behr for smaller or budget-conscious jobs, especially when a client doesn’t require the advanced features of higher-end Sherwin Williams lines. They appreciate the value for money, especially for interior projects in moderate-traffic areas like guest rooms or rental properties.

8.2 Real-Life Applications

  • Sherwin Williams Duration Paint: A Florida homeowner reported that even after five years of intense sunlight, humidity, and the occasional hurricane, the exterior still looked vibrant with minimal fading or cracking.
  • Behr Marquee Interior: A DIYer in California painted their entire living room with a single coat of this paint, praising its coverage and time-saving qualities.

8.3 Consumer Feedback

Online reviews generally place Sherwin Williams at the top for professional use, citing reliability for large-scale jobs. Behr stands out among homeowners who are cost-conscious yet still desire a polished result. Some negative reviews center around potential coverage issues—particularly for light colors over darker surfaces. Still, many of these complaints stem from lack of proper priming or user error.

9. Trends and Innovations

The paint industry is continually evolving, with brands introducing modern technologies, shifting color palettes, and expanding eco-friendly product lines.

9.1 Popular Color Trends

In 2025 and beyond, the focus remains on soothing neutrals mixed with bold accent hues. Here are some standouts:

  • Sherwin Williams Alabaster White: A warm, soft white that creates a cozy backdrop for Scandinavian or farmhouse-style interiors.
  • Behr Breezeway: A gentle green-gray that evokes calmness, perfect for bedroom retreats or serene living spaces.
  • Sherwin Williams Naval: A deep navy that can add drama when used on cabinets or statement walls.
  • Behr Black Evergreen: A moody, almost-black shade with a hint of forest green, bringing a sophisticated edge to modern designs.

9.2 Emerging Technologies

  • Smart Paints: Sherwin Williams is experimenting with thermochromatic coatings that change color based on temperature. While not yet mainstream, this technology hints at future possibilities.
  • Environmentally Reactive Formulations: Both brands are exploring paints with advanced mold and mildew inhibitors or self-cleaning properties—great news for high-humidity or high-pollen regions.

9.3 Future Projections

Experts predict that as the real estate market continues to evolve, premium paints will gain popularity for their longevity and lower lifetime costs. Eco-friendly solutions and minimalistic color palettes are likely to dominate home design in the coming years, with both Behr and Sherwin Williams continuing to refine existing product lines to meet these needs.

10. FAQs

  1. Q: Does one coat of Behr Marquee really cover everything?
    A: While Behr Marquee promises one-coat coverage for many colors, achieving complete coverage can depend on factors like the existing color, lighting conditions, and surface texture. Always have extra paint on hand for touch-ups.
  2. Q: Which paint is best for bathroom walls prone to mold or mildew?
    A: Sherwin Williams Duration Home or Bath Paint lines feature mildew-resistant technology. Behr’s Premium Plus Ultra also includes mildewcides, but Sherwin Williams has a slight edge for moisture-heavy rooms.
  3. Q: Can I use a standard brush or roller for both brands?
    A: Yes, but investing in high-quality brushes and rollers can improve finish and reduce streaks. Sherwin Williams paints are slightly thinner, so you might find them easier to work with when using a sprayer.
  4. Q: Do Behr and Sherwin Williams offer color consultations?
    A: Sherwin Williams provides in-store and online consultations, including expert advice on color palettes. Behr partners with Home Depot associates for color help, and the brand also has online tools for visualizing your space.
  5. Q: Which brand is more child-friendly and safe?
    A: Both brands offer low-VOC and zero-VOC lines. Sherwin Williams Harmony is zero-VOC and includes odor-absorbing technology, making it especially suitable for children’s rooms.
  6. Q: How do these brands fare on cabinets or furniture?
    A: Sherwin Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel is a popular choice for cabinetry due to its durability and smooth finish. Behr Interior/Exterior Enamel also provides a strong, hard finish. Prep is critical in both cases, including thorough sanding and priming.
  7. Q: Are there any major differences in warranties?
    A: Both brands offer limited lifetime warranties on select lines, though coverage nuances vary. Always review the specific product’s warranty details for what’s included or excluded.

11. Conclusion

A painter standing in a freshly painted room with tools in the background.

Choosing between Behr and Sherwin Williams boils down to budget, specific project needs, and personal preference. Let’s recap the key points:

  • Quality and Durability: Sherwin Williams often wins in categories like extreme durability and vibrant color retention, especially in harsh climates or high-traffic interiors.
  • Price and Accessibility: Behr is typically more budget-friendly and available at Home Depot stores nationwide, making it a straightforward choice for many homeowners.
  • Color Selection: While both brands offer thousands of options, Sherwin Williams’ ColorSnap® system stands out for professional-grade customization, whereas Behr’s Paint Visualizer simplifies DIY color planning.
  • Application and Consistency: Sherwin Williams paints tend to be slightly thinner, favoring professional sprayer techniques, while Behr’s thicker consistency can be more forgiving for beginners but may require more care to avoid brush or roller marks.
  • Environmental Considerations: Both brands now offer low-VOC and zero-VOC options, making them suitable for eco-conscious consumers. Sherwin Williams’ Harmony line is particularly notable for indoor air quality enhancements.

Ultimately, if you’re willing to pay a premium for what many professionals consider to be top-tier performance, Sherwin Williams is the way to go. If you prioritize affordability, ease of access, and a more DIY-friendly approach, Behr remains an excellent choice.

Regardless of which brand you select, remember that proper prep, quality tools, and good technique are vital. You can have the best paint money can buy, but if the walls aren’t clean, or if you rush through each coat, you won’t achieve optimal results. Take your time, follow the manufacturer’s directions, and consult in-store experts or brand websites for personalized advice.

12. Additional Resources

Final Thoughts and Community Sharing

Now that you’ve explored the nuances, performance, costs, and sustainability aspects of both Behr and Sherwin Williams, you’re equipped to tackle your next painting project with confidence. Whether you prioritize affordability and quick coverage, or prefer a high-end, professional finish with unmatched durability, both brands can help you achieve your dream interior or exterior look.

We want to hear from you! Have you recently painted a room, an entire home, or a piece of furniture using Behr or Sherwin Williams? Share your experiences, tips, or any unexpected discoveries in the comments below. By swapping stories and advice, we can all keep growing and improving our painting skills.

This article is provided for general informational purposes and is based on the author’s research and experience. Always consult the official brand guides or speak to a professional painter for tailored advice, especially when working on critical or complex painting projects.

Similar Posts